Although the end of a relationship can create a number of stressful challenges, the financial burden may be the most devastating. The high cost of divorce litigation, which can run anywhere from $15,000 to well over $50,000, motivates many to find a less contentious and more affordable way to approach separation. For couples in California, legal separation achieved through a cooperative process like mediation can offer exactly that.
What Is Legal Separation in California?
In California, a legal separation allows a couple to live separate lives while remaining legally married. It is a formal, court-ordered process that achieves many of the same outcomes as a dissolution of marriage, more commonly referred to as a “divorce.” Through a legal separation, a judge can issue legally binding orders to:
- Divide marital property, assets, and debts
- Establish child custody, visitation schedules, and child support
- Award spousal or domestic partner support
- Determine responsibility for attorneys’ fees
Although a legal separation addresses many of the same issues as a divorce, there are several crucial distinctions in the legal process and final outcome that set them apart.
Legal Separation vs. Divorce: Key Differences
Like a divorce, legal separations follow a structured process that requires filing a petition with the court. However, several important differences include:
- Marriage Status: The most significant difference between legal separation and divorce is that in a legal separation, you remain legally married and therefore cannot remarry. A divorce, on the other hand, terminates the marriage and returns both parties to the status of “single.”
- Waiting Period: California has a mandatory six-month waiting period for a divorce to be finalized. This period begins once the other spouse is served with the petition or files a response. Legal separation has no such waiting period and can be finalized more quickly.
- Court Forms: The process for divorce and separation both begin with the same form, the FL-100 Petition—Marriage/Domestic Partnership. However, separation involves checking the box indicating you are seeking a “legal separation” instead of a “dissolution.”
It’s important that all parties involved understand that legal separations are not the same as an informal agreement to “take a break” or live in separate residences. They require a petition to the court, and once a judge signs the judgment, they are legally binding and enforceable.
Why Couples Choose Legal Separation
The decision to pursue a legal separation instead of a divorce is often based on a mix of practical, personal, and financial considerations. Although the exact reasons can vary from person to person, the decision to separate typically revolves around residency requirements, personal beliefs, benefits, and family dynamics.
Meeting Divorce Residency Requirementsrior Privacy in Private Judging
A practical reason to file for legal separation is to start the legal process while waiting to qualify for a divorce. To file for divorce in California, at least one spouse must have lived in the state for the last six months and resided in the county where they plan to file for at least three months. Legal separations don’t have these time requirements; one spouse just needs to be a resident of California. This allows couples filing for legal separation to immediately address pressing issues like custody, support, and property division. Later, once the residency requirements are met, they can amend their petition to ask for a divorce, effectively getting a head start on the process.
Religious or Moral Beliefs
For individuals whose faith or deeply held personal convictions discourage or forbid divorce, legal separation provides a formal and legally binding way to live separate lives without officially dissolving the marriage. This allows them to maintain their commitments to their faith or principles while still creating the financial and physical separation they need to move forward.
Health Insurance and Other Benefits
A legal separation can allow a spouse to remain on the other’s health insurance plan, retain certain military benefits, or continue to collect Social Security that may be tied to the length of a marriage. In many cases, these benefits are immediately terminated upon a final divorce judgment, making a separation a financially sound choice for those who rely on them.
Emotional and Family Dynamics
When the future of a relationship is uncertain, a legal separation can serve as an official “pause” without the finality of divorce. It provides the space couples need to address their issues while living independently from one another. This less definitive step can also be a gentler transition for the entire family. For parents, it allows them to establish new routines and co-parenting dynamics without the immediate and often emotionally charged weight of a marriage dissolution, softening the adjustment period for them and their children.
What Legal Protections Are Offered by Separation?
In California, legal separation can provide many of the same protections as a divorce. A formal judgment of legal separation can:
- Create a legally enforceable arrangement of your marital assets and liabilities
- Award spousal support by ordering payments to a financially dependent spouse
- Establish child custody and visitation agreements, outlining parenting plans and responsibilities
- Prevent the creation of new shared debt by setting a formal date of separation, after which any new debt is generally the sole responsibility of the spouse who incurs it
While these protections provide a sense of structure and security during this major life transition, how you arrive at your agreements can make all the difference. With litigation, the process can be confrontational, invasive, and cost-prohibitive. Alternatives like mediation can not only save you money but, more importantly, reduce the stress on you and your family that often comes with going to court.
How Mediation Supports a Healthier Separation Process
Instead of an adversarial process where spouses are pitted against each other, mediation fosters cooperation and open communication. With the help of a neutral third-party mediator, couples can negotiate and reach a mutually acceptable agreement that meets their family’s specific needs.
The collaborative approach of mediation offers several key benefits over litigation:
- More Affordable: By avoiding lengthy court battles and extensive attorney involvement, mediation can be significantly more cost-effective than litigation.
- Private and Confidential: Unlike public court records, mediation sessions are private and confidential, allowing couples to discuss sensitive matters in a secure environment.
- Faster Resolution: Mediation can often be resolved more quickly than going through the court system, which can be subject to delays and backlogs.
Better, More Durable Agreements: Mediation allows couples to create customized agreements that reflect their unique circumstances, needs, and goals, rather than having a solution imposed by a judge. Because you both actively participate in creating the agreement, it’s more likely that both parties honor it long-term.
What to Expect During Legal Separation Mediation
The mediation process for a legal separation is designed to facilitate productive conversations and lead to a comprehensive agreement. While each mediator’s methods can differ, most mediation will involve all parties meeting for a series of sessions, either in person or over a video-conferencing platform like Zoom.
During these sessions, the mediator helps you tackle core subjects of your separation in a structured manner. You will address financial matters, such as the division of assets and debts, as well as any potential spousal support. The discussion will also cover practical housing issues, like determining who will live in the family home or making other living arrangements. For parents, significant time will be dedicated to child custody and support, with the goal of creating a parenting plan that serves the best interests of the children.
While you are not required to have attorneys present during mediation, you can still choose to have them review any proposed agreements before they are finalized. Once an agreement is reached, it can be submitted to the court for approval, at which point it becomes a legally enforceable judgment of legal separation.
Common Misconceptions About Legal Separation
Although legal separation can be a valuable and effective alternative to marriage dissolution, it is often misunderstood. Because it’s less common than divorce, several myths and misconceptions tend to cause confusion for couples weighing their options.
Myth: Legal Separation is Only for People Avoiding Divorce
While some couples choose legal separation as a permanent alternative to divorce for religious or personal reasons, many others use it as a transitional tool. It can serve as a “cooling-off” period to explore reconciliation or act as a necessary first step to establish boundaries before meeting the residency requirements for a divorce.
Myth: Living Apart is the Same as a Legal Separation
Simply moving into separate residences or having an informal agreement has no legal weight in California. A legal separation is a formal court process that requires filing a petition and receiving a judgment from a judge. Without this formal decree, your assets, debts, and legal responsibilities remain entangled as if you were still living together.
Myth: A Legal Separation is Permanent
A judgment of legal separation is not set in stone. It is a flexible legal status that can be modified. If a couple who is legally separated later decides they want to end their marriage, they can petition the court to convert their legal separation into a final divorce decree, often without having to start the entire process from scratch.
Myth: Legal Separation is Always Cheaper Than Divorce
The legal work required for a separation, including valuing property, creating custody plans, and calculating support, is nearly identical to that of a divorce. Therefore, the base cost can be very similar. The most significant cost savings come from the process you use to reach that agreement. This leads many couples to use alternatives like mediation, which can be dramatically less expensive than hashing out disagreements in a public courtroom.
Takeaway
In California, legal separation is an alternative to divorce that follows a similar process and offers many of the same protections. The primary difference is that, while a divorce officially dissolves a marriage, a separation leaves the legal status of a marriage intact.
Couples choose separation over divorce for a variety of reasons, including:
- Meeting divorce residency requirements
- Religious and moral beliefs
- Health insurance and other benefits
- Emotional and family dynamics
While family court is often thought of as the default path to divorce or separation, choosing to go to court is frequently more stressful and expensive than alternatives like mediation. A professional mediator can offer a neutral and private environment to build an agreement that satisfies both parties, without the conflict or cost of a courtroom.
Not sure whether divorce or legal separation is right for you?
We’ll help you explore your options and choose the best path forward—for you and your family.
Schedule a confidential consultation with Forester Family Law.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Legal Separation in California
What Happens When You Legally Separate in California?
Legal separation in California involves going through a formal court process that typically results in a legally binding judgment. This judgment settles numerous issues, including the division of property and debts, child custody, and spousal support. Separation can allow spouses to live completely separate financial and domestic lives, but unlike a divorce, their marriage is not dissolved. Separated individuals remain legally married, meaning they are not free to remarry until a divorce is pursued and finalized.
What Are the Disadvantages of a Legal Separation?
The primary disadvantage of legal separation is that you are not free to remarry, which can be challenging to deal with emotionally. Additionally, while one of the main benefits of separation is the preservation of health insurance or military benefits, this is not guaranteed and depends entirely on the specific policy’s rules. Legal separation is also not automatically cheaper than a divorce, as the legal work involved is nearly identical, though using alternatives like mediation can result in significant cost savings.
Does Legal Separation Protect Me Financially in California?
Yes, financial protection is one of the most important benefits of a legal separation. The court judgment establishes a formal date of separation, and from that date forward, any new debt incurred by your spouse is their sole responsibility. Additionally, any income you earn is your separate property. The judgment will also formally divide all existing marital assets and debts, creating a clear, enforceable financial boundary between you and your spouse.